2000
Kid A (Radiohead)
2001
Is This It? (The Strokes)
Turn on the Bright Lights (Interpol)
2002
( ) (Sigur Ros)
By The Way (The Red Hot Chili Peppers)
Kill the Moonlight (Spoon)
In Full Swing (Mark O’Conner’s Hot Swing Trio)
2003
Hail to the Thief (Radiohead)
2004
How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb (U2)
Music for Two (Edgar Meyer and Bela Fleck)
Keyed Up (Vasen)
Rubber Factory (The Black Keys)
Turbo (Hoven Droven)
Funeral (The Arcade Fire)
2005
Nothing is Sound (Switchfoot)
2006
The Eraser
Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I’m Not (Arctic Monkeys)
The Crane Wife (The Decemberists)
2007
Armchair Apocrypha (Andrew Bird)
Emotionalism (The Avett Brothers)
Prog (The Bad Plus)
Super Taranta! (Gogol Bordello)
We Were Dead Before the Ship Even Sank (Modest Mouse)
Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga (Spoon)
Icky Thump (The White Stripes)
In Rainbows (Radiohead)
Neon Bible (The Arcade Fire)
2009
Dragonslayer (Sunset Rubdown)
Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix (Phoenix)
Horehound (The Dead Weather)
Kid A: In my opinion, the best album (rock or otherwise) ever made. I can listen to Kid A beginning to end endless times and it only gets better. I am a proponent of the unified album as a work of art, and this is the preeminent example of that.
Is This It? and Turn On The Bright Lights: both great debut albums from bands whose second albums where also good, but then slid pretty heavily on their third.
( ): post-rock comprised of songs without titles and a made-up phonetic language based on icelandic. It is spare and starkly beautiful, the songs build on themselves gradually before collapsing back onto themselves.
By the Way: The best chili peppers album, funky and driving and messy and delightful.
Kill the Moonlight: Very possibly Spoon's best album. Meticulously crafted songs, stabbing piano chords, extremely groovy, and of course Britt Daniel's great voice.
In Full Swing: Lovely swing/jazz album with great collaborators (Jane Monheit, Wynton Marsalis) from one of my favorite violinists.
Hail to the Thief: The most underrated Radiohead album. It drags a bit in the middle, however it communicates a certain paranoia/fear/creepiness that I think is unsurpassed and chillingly enjoyable.
Atomic Bomb: I know, I know, you aren't supposed to like newer U2. This just happens to be the first rock album I ever owned/had on my ipod/listened to all the way through more than once. I still think it is pretty good, better than No Line on the Horizon in any case.
Music for Two: The best living Bass Player and the best Banjo player in the world playing songs they wrote together live. Influenced by bluegrass/classical, technically stunning playing.
Keyed Up: Vasen is a Swedish viola/nyckelharpa/12 string guitar trio that used to be my favorite band. I have seen them live several times. They play traditional and original compositions with amazing energy and passion.
Rubber Factory: This list probably under represents how much I like blues music. Rubber Factory is red-hot blues-rock, searingly good. There is just something about blues guitar I cannot get enough of.
Turbo: Swedish roots-rock. Loads of fun (for me anyway . . . )
Funeral: It seems to me that few bands can play of of raw emotion and not come of sounding overdone or stupid, and Arcade Fire is one of the few. The entire album bleeds passion while being original in its sound. (They also use live strings, which makes me happy).
Nothing is Sound: There is just something about this album in its mood and lyrics that resonates with me. I don't think Switchfoot are very original, but they use the influences they draw from to create a very entertaining an polished sound.
The Eraser: Thom Yorke's solo album which in many ways sounds like Radiohead if all they had was a laptop and more than the usual amount of paranoia. One of the only albums that could be put under the genre electronic that I listen to.
Whatever People Say I Am: The Arctic Monkey's first, and I think best album so far. Guitar-driven British rock and not much more, but still great.
The Crane Wife: Solid Decembrists album. Some think the band's lyrics are pretentious, but I think that misses what they are trying to do. They often tell stories in their songs, which lends itself to literary language. The fact that it can be over-done is exactly part of the effect they are going for.
Armchair Apocrypha: Andrew Byrd sings, plays the violin and guitar, and whistles. Often at the same time. He also writes beautiful music, and this is one of his best albums.
Emotionalism: My favorite album from the Avett Brothers, also likely my favorite straightforward bluegrass album.
Prog: Also not enough Jazz on this list. The Bad Plus are an amazing progressive jazz/jazz-rock bass/piano/drums trio. They do sprawling rock covers and original pieces, generally deconstruction songs to the point that they cannot be recognized while still somehow remaining together.
Super Taranta!: Two words. Gypsy-Punk. If you don't like it, you need to have more fun.
We Were Dead: Isaac Brock's voice seems to be a kind of love/hate issue for most people. He tends to talk, growl, yelp, and scream a lot along with some singing, and I get that many don't like it. However, I really enjoy Modest Mouse's music as a whole, especially the excellent use of strings on this album.
Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga: A real grower of an album, also probably Spoon's most enjoyable LP.
Icky Thump: My favorite Stripes album. Loud and bluesy (also there is a bagpipe).
In Rainbows: Really just a flat-out beautiful album. Every song is so well-constructed and it manages to be Radiohead's most accessible album while not really sounding like any other band.
Neon Bible: Offers a stinging critique of much of what is wrong with organized religion with a passion that shows how much Arcade Fire cares about it. It was recorded in churches and makes stunning use of pipe organs.
Dragonslayer: Slightly odd indie-rock that has grown on me a lot. The songs are complex and you tend to get more out of them with every listen.
Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix: Very catchy alternative rock from France.
Horehound: Jack White with Alison Mosshart of the Kills and the bass player from Raconteurs and the guitarist from Queens of the Stone Age. Jack White plays drums on the album. He originally played the drums before he took up the guitar, and is actually very good. The whole album has a great blues/gothic feel and Mosshart uses her impressive voice well.